One more time about “the problem of Seljuk art”
Abstract
The article deals with the history of so-called “Seljuk problem” in Eastern art historiography. Native researchers had to return to this problem more then once. It was caused by high quality of artistic monuments, architectural first of all, dating back not only to the time of Great Seljuk State, and extended to the large territories subordinate to Turkic dynasties. Were Turk-Seljuks real creators of enormous number of “Seljuk art” monuments, or one can speak only about making the favorable conditions for local art schools and state-guaranteed orders? Impossibility of simple answer results in concealment of Seljuk period, which weakens down the idea of Muslim architectural development.
Keywords:
Seljuk, art of Islam, typology of Muslim architecture, Turkish architecture, local traditions, mosque, mausoleum
Downloads
Download data is not yet available.
References
Литература
1. Cahen C. Pre-Ottoman Turkey: a general survey of the material and spiritual culture and history c. 1071–1330. N. Y.: Taplinger Publishing Co, 1968. 480 p.
2. Гордлевский В. Государство Сельджукидов Малой Азии. М.; Л.: Изд-во АН СССР, 1941. 204 с.
3. Bü yü k Selç uklu miras: mimari / Heritage of The Great Seljuks. Architecture. Vol. 1–3. Istanbul: Kristal Matbaacilik San. Tc. Ltd., 2013.
4. Шукуров Ш. М. Образ Храма. М.: Прогресс-Традиция, 2002. 496 с.
5. Стародуб Т. Х. Сокровища исламской архитектуры. М.: Белый город, 2004. 456 с.
6. Хмельницкий С. Г. Между Саманидами и монголами. Архитектура Средней Азии XI — начала XIII вв. Часть I. Берлин—Рига: Gamajun, 1996. 336 с.
7. Petersen A. Dictionary of Islamic Architecture. L.; N. Y.: Taylor & Fransis, 2002. 342 p.
8. Зиливинская Э. Д. Архитектура Золотой Орды. Часть I. Культовое зодчество. М.; Казань: Отечество, 2014. 446 с.
9. Садр ад-Дин, Али ал-Хусайни. Ахбар ад-даулат ас-сельджукийа (Сообщения о сельджукском государстве. Сливки летописей, сообщавших о сельджукских эмирах и государях). М.: Восточная литература, 1980. 521 с.
10. Кононенко Е. И. Анатолийские мечети Великих Сельджуков: архитектурные и политические ориентиры // Искусствознание. 2015. № 3–4. (в печати).
11. Кононенко Е. И. «Сельджукский портал»: архитектурная декорация как средство политической риторики // Вестник С.-Петерб. ун-та. Серия 15. Искусствоведение. 2015. № 1. C. 134–144.
12. The Cambridge History of Islam. Vol. 1A. The Central Islamic Lands from pre-islamic times to the Ist World War / ed. P. M. Holt, A. Lambton, B. Lewis. L.; N. Y.: Сambridge University press, 2005 [1970]. 523 p.
13. Орбели И. Проблема сельджукского искусства // III Международный конгресс по иранскому искусству и археологии. Доклады. М.; Л.: Изд-во АН СССР, 1939. 301 с.
14. Пугаченкова Г. А. Пути развития архитектуры южного Туркменистана поры рабовладения и феодализма. М.: Изд-во АН СССР, 1958. 491 с. (Труды ЮТАКЭ. Т. 6).
15. Ремпель Л. Архитектурный орнамент южного Туркменистана X — начала XIII вв. и проблемы «сельджукского стиля» // Труды ЮТАКЭ. 1963. Т. XII. C. 249–308.
16. Ремпель Л. И. Искусство среднеазиатского Междуречья XI — начала XIII века // Ремпель Л. И. Искусство Среднего Востока. Избранные труды. М.: Советский художник, 1978. C. 42–111.
17. Aslanapa O. Türk Sanati. D. I–II. Istanbul: Kervan, 1984. 416 p.
18. Бретаницкий Л. С. Художественное наследие Переднего Востока эпохи феодализма: Избранные труды. М.: Советский художник, 1987. 255 с.
19. Osmanli mimarisi / Usul-i Mi’mari-i Osmani. Istanbul: Ç amlica, 2010 [1873]. 256 p.
20. Arseven G. E. L’Art Turc depuis son origine jusqu’a nos jours. Istanbul: Devlet Basimevi, 1939. 305 p.
21. Брунов Н. И. Очерки по истории архитектуры: в 2 т. М.: ЗАО Центрполиграф, 2003 [1937]. Т. 1. 398 с.
22. Миллер Ю. Искусство Турции. М.; Л.: Искусство, 1965. 168 c.
23. Бородина И. Ф. Архитектура Турции XII–XIX вв. // Всеобщая история архитектуры. Т. 8. Архитектура стран Средиземноморья, Африки и Азии. М.: Стройиздат, 1969. C. 427–476.
24. The Cambridge History of Turkey. Vol. 1. Byzantium to Turkey, 1071–1453 / ed. K. Fleet. L.; N. Y.: Сambridge University press, 2009. 522 p.
25. Рахманалиев Р. Империя тюрков. Великая цивилизация. М.: РИПОЛ классик, 2009. 742 с.
26. Koprulu M. F. The Seljuks of Anatolia: their history and culture according to local muslim sources. Salt Lake City: University of Utah Press, 1992 [1943]. 141 p.
27. Savvides A. G. C. Some major Seljuk, Persian and Ottoman sources regarding Byzantine-Seljuk relations (A bibliographical survey) // Mesogeios. 2005. № 25–26. C. 9–26.
28. Запорожец В. М. Сельджуки. М.: Воениздат, 2011. 295 с.
References
1. Cahen C. Pre-Ottoman Turkey: a general survey of the material and spiritual culture and history c. 1071–1330. New York, Taplinger Publishing Co, 1968. 480 p.
2. Gordlevskii V. Gosudarstvo Sel’dzhukidov Maloi Azii [The Seljukid State of Anatolia]. Moscow, Leningrad, AN SSSR Publ., 1941. 204 p. (In Russian)
3. Bü yü k Selç uklu miras: mimari. Heritage of The Great Seljuks. Architecture, vol. 1–3. Istanbul: Kristal Matbaacilik San. Tc. Ltd., 2013.
4. Shukurov Sh. M. Obraz Khrama [The Image of Temple]. Moscow, Progress-Traditsiia Publ., 2002. 496 p. (In Russian)
5. Starodub T. Kh. Sokrovishcha islamskoi arkhitektury [The Treasures of Muslim Architecture]. Moscow, Belyi gorod Publ., 2004. 456 p. (In Russian)
6. Khmel’nitskii S. G. Mezhdu Samanidami i mongolami. Arkhitektura Srednei Azii XI — nachala XIII vv. [Between Samanids and Mongols. Architecture of Middle Asia 11th — early 13th cent.]. Part I. Berlin—Riga, Gamajun Publ., 1996. 336 p. (In Russian)
7. Petersen A. Dictionary of Islamic Architecture. London, New York, Taylor & Fransis, 2002. 342 p.
8. Zilivinskaia E. D. Arkhitektura Zolotoi Ordy. Chast’ I. Kul’tovoe zodchestvo [The Golden Horde architecture. Part I. Cult monuments]. Moscow, Kazan, Otechestvo Publ., 2014. 446 p.
9. Sadr ad-Din, Ali al-Khusaini. Akhbar ad-daulat as-sel’dzhukiia (Soobshcheniia o sel’dzhukskom gosudarstve. Slivki letopisei, soobshchavshikh o sel’dzhukskikh emirakh i gosudariakh) [Reports about the Seljuk state. The cream or chronicles that reported about the Seljuk emirs and sovereigns]. Moscow, Vostochnaia literatura Publ., 1980. 521 p. (In Russian)
10. Kononenko E. I. Anatoliiskie mecheti Velikikh Sel’dzhukov: arkhitekturnye i politicheskie orientiry [Anatolian mosques of the Great Seljuks: architectural and political landmarks]. Iskusstvoznanie [Art Studies], 2015, no. 3–4. (in press). (In Russian)
11. Kononenko E. I. “Sel’dzhukskii portal”: arkhitekturnaia dekoratsiia kak sredstvo politicheskoi ritoriki [“Seljuq portal”: architectural decoration as the method of political rhetoric]. Vestnik of Saint-Petersburg University. Series 15. Arts. 2015, no. 1, pp. 134–144. (In Russian)
12. The Cambridge History of Islam, vol. 1A. The Central Islamic Lands from pre-islamic times to the Ist World War. Eds P. M. Holt, A. Lambton, B. Lewis. London, New York, Сambridge University press, 2005 [1970]. 523 p.
13. Orbeli I. Problema sel’dzhukskogo iskusstva [The problem of Seljuk art]. III Mezhdunarodnyi kongress po iranskomu iskusstvu i arkheologii. Doklady [III International congress of Iranian Art and Archaeology. Reports]. Moscow, Leningrad, AN SSSR Publ., 1939. 301 p. (In Russian)
14. Pugachenkova G. A. Puti razvitiia arkhitektury iuzhnogo Turkmenistana pory rabovladeniia i feodalizma [The ways of development of the South Turkmenistan architecture at the times of slavery and feudalism]. Moscow, AN SSSR Publ., 1958. 491 p. (Trudy IuTAKE [Transactions of South Turkestan archaeological complex expedition], vol. 6). (In Russian)
15. Rempel’ L. Arkhitekturnyi ornament iuzhnogo Turkmenistana 10th — nachala 13th vv. i problemy “sel’dzhukskogo stilia” [The architectural ornament of South Turkmenistan X — early XIII cent. and the problems of “Seljuk style”]. Trudy IuTAKE [Transactions of South Turkestan archaeological complex expedition], 1963, vol. XII, pp. 249–308. (In Russian)
16. Rempel’ L. I. Iskusstvo sredneaziatskogo Mezhdurech’ia XI — nachala XIII veka [The Art of Middle Asia interfluve 11th — early 13th cent.]. Rempel’ L. I. Iskusstvo Srednego Vostoka. Izbrannye trudy [Art of Middle East. Selected works]. Moscow, Sovetskii khudozhnik Publ., 1978, pp. 42–111. (In Russian)
17. Aslanapa O. Türk Sanati. D. I–II [The art of Turks. Vol. I–II]. Istanbul, Kervan, 1984. 416 p.
18. Bretanitskii L. S. Khudozhestvennoe nasledie Perednego Vostoka epokhi feodalizma: Izbrannye trudy [The artistic heritage of Western Orient on the feudal period: Selected works]. Moscow, Sovetskii khudozhnik Publ., 1987. 255 p. (In Russian)
19. Osmanli mimarisi. Usul-i Mi’mari-i Osmani [Osmanian architecture]. Istanbul, Ç amlica, 2010 [1873]. 256 p.
20. Arseven G. E. L’Art Turc depuis son origine jusqu’a nos jours [Turkish art from the beginning to present days]. Istanbul, Devlet Basimevi, 1939. 305 p.
21. Brunov N. I. Ocherki po istorii arkhitektury [Essays on the history of architecture]: in 2 vols. Moscow, ZAO Tsentrpoligraf Publ., 2003 [1937], vol. 1. 398 p. (In Russian)
22. Miller Iu. Iskusstvo Turtsii [The art of Turkey]. Moscow, Leningrad, Iskusstvo Publ., 1965. 168 p. (In Russian)
23. Borodina I. F. Arkhitektura Turtsii XII–XIX vv. [The architecture of Turkey 12th–19th cent.]. Vseobshchaia istoriia arkhitektury. T. 8. Arkhitektura stran Sredizemnomor’ia, Afriki i Azii [The general history of architecture. Vol. 8. Architecture of Mediterranean, Africa and Asia]. Moscow, Stroiizdat Publ., 1969, pp. 427–476. (In Russian)
24. The Cambridge History of Turkey, vol. 1. Byzantium to Turkey, 1071–1453. Ed. by K. Fleet. London, New York, Сambridge University press, 2009. 522 p.
25. Rakhmanaliev R. Imperiia tiurkov. Velikaia tsivilizatsiia [The empire of turks. The great civilization]. Moscow, RIPOL klassik Publ., 2009. 742 p. (In Russian)
26. Koprulu M. F. The Seljuks of Anatolia: their history and culture according to local muslim sources. Salt Lake City, University of Utah Press, 1992 [1943]. 141 p.
27. Savvides A. G. C. Some major Seljuk, Persian and Ottoman sources regarding Byzantine-Seljuk relations (A bibliographical survey). Mesogeios, 2005, no. 25–26, pp. 9–26.
28. Zaporozhets V. M. Sel’dzhuki [The Seljuks]. Moscow, Voenizdat Publ., 2011. 295 p. (In Russian)
Downloads
Published
2015-11-06
How to Cite
Kononenko, E. I. . (2015). One more time about “the problem of Seljuk art”. Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Arts, 5(3), 66–77. Retrieved from https://artsjournal.spbu.ru/article/view/2094
Issue
Section
Architecture
License
Articles of "Vestnik of Saint Petersburg University. Arts" are open access distributed under the terms of the License Agreement with Saint Petersburg State University, which permits to the authors unrestricted distribution and self-archiving free of charge.
